Yet-Forward Feedback is an approach to feedback that looks toward what someone can become, not only at what went wrong. It begins with a hypothesis I hold lightly. Feedback tends to land as an invitation when it points forward, keeps yet in view, and asks before telling. Backward-looking criticism, by contrast, often lands as a verdict, and verdicts invite defense. On this page, we explore SBIQO, a five-step structure: Situation, Behavior, Impact, Open Question, and Opportunity. Along the way, we also look at the research behind it and the places where it can still go wrong.
Most of us remember feedback that changed us. Many of us also remember feedback that simply stung. Often, the difference had less to do with the content than with its direction. One kind looked back and judged. The other kind looked ahead and invited. That difference is what this page explores, one question at a time.
A Brief Podcast Dialog Summarizing the Concepts Explored Below
Yet-Forward Feedback at a Glance
In short, Yet-Forward Feedback starts with a shared direction, keeps the backward look brief, and gives most of the conversation to what comes next.
| Element | What it does | Sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| Shared direction | Invites, rather than assesses, and asks permission | “I’d love to help you be even more effective. May I share something I noticed?” |
| Situation, Behavior, Impact | Establishes shared facts in about three sentences together | “In Tuesday’s planning meeting, you committed to the Q1 date before checking with engineering. The team went into scramble mode.” |
| Open Question | Asks before telling, inviting their perspective and intent | “What were you weighing in that moment?” |
| Opportunity | Names a next step, ideally in their own words | “What might you try at the next roadmap review?” |
| Yet | Frames a gap as a point on a path toward their own aspiration | “You’re not yet running these meetings at the level you want.” |
For a printable summary, see the one-page Yet-Forward Feedback guide.
Table of Contents
- The Yet-Forward Feedback Conversation Every Manager Dreaded
- Why Backward-Looking Feedback So Often Backfires
- Yet-Forward Feedback Begins With a Shared Direction
- The Quiet Power of Yet
- SBIQO: The Five Steps of Yet-Forward Feedback
- Open Questions That Keep Feedback Forward
- Yet-Forward Feedback When Something Went Well
- Where Yet-Forward Feedback Can Go Wrong
- A Yet-Forward Feedback Conversation About a Promotion
- Practicing Yet-Forward Feedback With AI
- Questions to Carry Into Your Next Feedback Conversation
- How Yet-Forward Feedback Compares With Other Feedback Models
- Glossary of Yet-Forward Feedback Terms
- Frequently Asked Questions About Yet-Forward Feedback
- See Also
- Slide Deck
The Yet-Forward Feedback Conversation Every Manager Dreaded
Yet-Forward Feedback became vivid for me during a management training session at a company where I worked. The company had hired professional actors to play especially difficult employees. The facilitator opened with a scenario for a room of first, second, and third-line managers. Imagine it is annual review time. Your employee is struggling and never seems to hear or act on feedback. Even so, they feel undervalued, underpaid, and deserving of a raise and a promotion. Who would dread that conversation?
Every hand in the room went up, except mine. Puzzled, the facilitator asked why the prospect did not make me cringe. Perhaps I’m a bit of a sick puppy, I answered, but those are the conversations I most look forward to. Here was someone with high ambition and real passion. They also had many opportunities for growth they could not yet see. To me, that combination felt like a gold mine.
After all, I could acknowledge their desire for a raise and a promotion. Then I could tell them I saw a path to both, and ask whether they wanted to explore it together. That shift changed my place in the conversation. I was no longer delivering backward-looking criticism they would need to defend against. Instead, I was offering a path toward something they already wanted. Consequently, the conversation could begin from curiosity rather than self-protection.
The facilitators then paired me with their most challenging actor, who threw everything at me. Each objection, however, revealed something the employee cared about. In every area, we found an opportunity they could get genuinely excited about. By the end, the feedback no longer felt like a verdict. Instead, it felt like a plan they wanted to own.
Why Backward-Looking Feedback So Often Backfires
Backward-looking feedback focuses on what already happened, and that focus carries a hidden cost. The past cannot change, so the listener can only accept the judgment or defend against it. As a result, much of the conversation’s energy goes into protection rather than learning. In my experience, people rarely grow while they are busy defending themselves.
Research offers a sobering signal here. In 1996, Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi reviewed hundreds of feedback studies. On average, feedback improved performance. Yet in over a third of the cases, feedback actually made performance worse. Their analysis suggested a pattern worth noticing. Feedback seemed to lose effectiveness as it drew attention away from the task and toward the self.
That finding echoes something we explore in Evaluation and Motivation. People often hear evaluation as a signal about whether they still belong. When that happens, even accurate feedback can feel like a threat. Consequently, the listener narrows, guards, and waits for the conversation to end. The feedback may be correct, and still it fails to help.
Everyday experience at work seems to echo that research. In Gallup’s research, only 26% of employees strongly agree that their feedback helps them do better work. In other words, most feedback may not be landing as help.
None of this means the past is irrelevant. Instead, it suggests the past works best as context rather than as the destination. The question then becomes how to honor what happened while pointing attention toward what comes next.
Yet-Forward Feedback Begins With a Shared Direction
Yet-Forward Feedback starts before the first observation, with a shared sense of where the conversation is heading. I prefer to open with an invitation rather than an assessment. For example: “I’d love to help you be even more effective at leading these meetings. May I share something I noticed?” That single sentence changes the frame. It signals that the purpose is growth, and it gives the other person a choice.
Asking permission matters more than it might seem. When someone agrees to hear an observation, they enter the conversation as a participant. Without that agreement, they may feel ambushed, however kind our intent. Moreover, the invitation names a destination both people can want. “More effective” is a place someone can walk toward. “What you did wrong” is a place they can only retreat from.
In Curiosity Reciprocity, we explore why these first moments matter so much. Early signals tend to set the frame for everything that follows. Once defensiveness takes hold, it takes far more effort to loosen. A gentle, curious opening is therefore not a pleasantry. Instead, it shapes the whole conversation.
This framing owes a great deal to Marshall Goldsmith’s idea of feedforward. He observed that we can change the future but not the past. He also noticed that suggestions about the future rarely feel like personal attacks. Yet-Forward Feedback builds on that insight. However, it keeps an honest anchor in what actually happened, because direction without grounding can drift into vague encouragement.
The Quiet Power of Yet
The word yet may be the smallest tool in Yet-Forward Feedback, and perhaps the most important one. Compare two sentences. “You don’t run these meetings well.” Then: “You’re not yet running these meetings at the level you want.” The first describes a fixed state. The second describes a point on a path, and it assumes movement.
Carol Dweck popularized this idea through her mindset research and a talk on believing you can improve. She described schools that gave a grade of “Not Yet” instead of a failing mark. The grade told students they were on a learning curve rather than at a dead end. In the same way, yet in feedback treats a gap as temporary and closable.
Notice, too, a subtle phrase in that example: “the level you want.” When the standard belongs to the other person, yet becomes an ally of their own aspiration. In contrast, when the standard belongs only to us, yet can sound like a polite deadline. The word carries the most weight when it points toward something the listener already cares about.
Still, I want to hold this lightly. The research on growth mindset interventions remains genuinely contested, as we explore below. Yet is not a magic word. Rather, it is a small linguistic cue that can shift attention from who someone is to where they are going.
Yet-Forward Feedback in Performance Reviews
In performance reviews, the word yet finds a natural home in a levels matrix. I have carried and customized one from role to role. Its rows describe levels, and its columns describe skills. Each cell describes what that skill looks like at that level. For me, it offers one of the firmest foundations for Yet-Forward Feedback.
Together, we first decide on the year’s aim. Is the goal excellence across the skills at their current level? Or is the goal to level up? Then we look at areas where they have not yet had the opportunity to demonstrate proficiency. Notably, I never describe these as areas where they are deficient or have failed.
Nor am I questioning whether they are proficient yet. Instead, we look together for opportunities to demonstrate it. I offer to help find those opportunities and to make sure the expectations are clear. Then I support them in showing proficiency or excellence when the moment comes. They have not proven it yet, and I am showing them I believe they can. In that conversation, I sit on their side of the table, working in their best interest.
Wise Feedback: Nineteen Words Before the Feedback
youtu.be/a-OIRWujSmc
In a set of classroom experiments, David Yeager and colleagues asked teachers to attach a brief note to their critical feedback on student essays: “I’m giving you these comments because I have very high expectations and I know that you can reach them.” Students who received it were more likely to revise their work, especially those who mistrusted school. Adam Grant calls it one of his favorite experiments.
Like yet, those words work only when they are true. Said as a technique, high expectations can sound like pressure, and confidence can sound hollow. Said sincerely, they tell someone we are on their side of the table.
SBIQO: The Five Steps of Yet-Forward Feedback
SBIQO gives Yet-Forward Feedback a structure that stays grounded while it moves forward. It extends the Situation-Behavior-Impact model, which the Center for Creative Leadership developed. SBI keeps feedback specific, observable, and free of judgment. However, SBI ends with a statement, and statements often end conversations. SBIQO adds two steps, an Open Question and an Opportunity, so the conversation can keep going.
| Step | What it does | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Situation | Anchors the where and when | “In Tuesday’s planning meeting…” |
| Behavior | Names what was observable, without judgment | “…you committed to the Q1 date before checking with engineering.” |
| Impact | Shares the effect on you or others | “The team went into scramble mode, and two people asked me if the date was real.” |
| Open Question | Invites their perspective and intent | “What were you weighing in that moment?” |
| Opportunity | Looks forward, ideally in their words | “What might you try at the next roadmap review?” |
Together, Situation, Behavior, and Impact take about three sentences. Most of the conversation belongs to the Open Question and the Opportunity.
Situation, Behavior, and Impact as Brief Context
The first three steps are the backward-looking part of SBIQO, so I try to keep them brief. Ideally, Situation, Behavior, and Impact take about three sentences together. They establish shared facts and an honest account of effect. Then they step aside. Their job is to give the conversation solid ground, not to become its center.
Precision here protects the other person. “You were dismissive” is an interpretation, and it invites argument. “You looked at your phone while Maria was presenting” is an observation. Likewise, describing impact in terms of what you or others experienced keeps it honest. It reports an effect rather than diagnosing a character.
The Open Question Comes Before the Opportunity
The Open Question is where SBIQO turns from telling to inquiry. A genuine question invites the other person to share intent, context, and pressures we may not have seen. The Center for Creative Leadership later added an “Intent” step to its own model for a similar reason. Asking often reveals that the story in our head was incomplete.
Not every useful question needs to be powerful. Sometimes we first need a clarifying question to understand what happened. Then, more powerful questions can help someone explore assumptions, motivations, and possibilities. The Consultancy Protocol makes a similar distinction between clarifying and probing questions. Both have their place in SBIQO. What matters is resisting the temptation to offer solutions before we understand the situation.
The order matters. When someone diagnoses a situation themselves, they tend to own what follows. When we lead with our solution, we quietly return to telling. Furthermore, the answer to our question may change the Opportunity entirely. Sometimes it reveals that no change is needed at all.
Many leaders, myself included, feel a strong pull toward fixing. In Curiosity Reciprocity, we call this executive fix-it mode. Liz Wiseman describes leaders who rescue too quickly as accidental diminishers. However well meant, their speed takes the problem away from the person who owns it. The Open Question slows us down just enough to let the other person think first.
The Opportunity Belongs to Them
The Opportunity is the forward-looking heart of SBIQO and the place where yet does its work. Ideally, the other person names it first. Our role is then to affirm it, build on it, and offer support. If they don’t see one, we can offer a suggestion as a possibility rather than a prescription.
For this reason, I find it helpful to give most of the conversation’s time to the Question and the Opportunity. The proportion itself sends a message. It tells the other person that this conversation is mostly about their future, and only briefly about their past.
Open Questions That Keep Feedback Forward
The questions we ask largely determine whether Yet-Forward Feedback stays open or quietly closes. A question that already contains its answer is really a statement in disguise. By contrast, a genuine question leaves room for something we did not expect. The following questions are starting points, not scripts. You can find many more in Powerful Questions.
Questions That Explore Intent
- What was going on for you in that moment?
- How did it look from where you were sitting?
- What were you hoping would happen?
- How did you come to see it that way?
Questions That Invite Their Own Assessment
One of the most revealing questions I have used asks people to predict how others see them. At one company, our reviews gathered three perspectives beyond the manager’s view. Employees wrote a self-review and received 360 feedback from colleagues. They also predicted what that 360 feedback would say. That third perspective often proved the most valuable, because it so often differed from what colleagues actually wrote.
Repeatedly, people expected criticism where their colleagues offered praise. One engineer predicted colleagues would call her too opinionated, always having something to say. Instead, her colleagues described her comments as insightful and well delivered. Several wished she would speak up more. Over the years, I have seen that same disconnect in three engineers at three different companies. As a result, I suspect many of us walk into feedback already braced for judgment. The gap itself then opens a forward-looking question about what to do more of.
- How do you think others see you here?
- How do you think it landed?
- What would you keep, and what would you change?
- What did you notice that I might have missed?
Questions That Open the Opportunity
- What would “even more effective” look like for you here?
- What might you try next time?
- What isn’t possible for you yet that you’d like to be?
- How could I support that?
Questions That Are Verdicts in Disguise
Some questions sound open but close the door instead. “Why would you do that?” and “Don’t you think that was a problem?” both end with a question mark. Even so, both carry a judgment the listener must either accept or resist. A useful test is simple. If we already know the answer we want, the question is not open yet.
Sounds Like a Verdict, or Sounds Like Yet-Forward
Small shifts in wording can change how feedback lands. Most of the pairs below draw on examples from this page.
| Sounds like a verdict | Sounds like Yet-Forward |
|---|---|
| “You don’t run these meetings well.” | “You’re not yet running these meetings at the level you want.” |
| “You were dismissive.” | “You looked at your phone while Maria was presenting.” |
| “Why would you do that?” | “What was going on for you in that moment?” |
| “Here’s what you need to do next time.” | “What might you try at the next roadmap review?” |
| “Great job.” | “What made that work for you? Where else might that help?” |
Yet-Forward Feedback When Something Went Well
Yet-Forward Feedback is not only for difficult conversations. In fact, it may be equally valuable when something went well. Praise often stops at “great job,” which feels good but teaches little. When we add a question and an opportunity, appreciation becomes something the person can understand and repeat.
For example, we might say: “In yesterday’s client call, you paused and summarized their concern before answering. They visibly relaxed, and the whole tone shifted.” Then we can ask, “What made that work for you?” Finally, we can open the opportunity: “Where else might that help?” In this way, a single moment becomes a pattern the person can choose again.
Sometimes the most useful forward-looking feedback is simply an invitation to do more. The engineer who feared seeming too opinionated needed exactly that. Her colleagues were not asking her to change course. Rather, they were asking her to step further into a strength she had underestimated.
There is a quieter benefit as well. When people receive Yet-Forward Feedback for their strengths, they learn that feedback conversations are safe. As a result, the harder conversations that come later begin on firmer ground.
Where Yet-Forward Feedback Can Go Wrong
Yet-Forward Feedback has limits, and naming them honestly seems more useful than defending the approach. I offer these not as reasons to abandon it, but as places to stay alert. Each one emerged from asking what might make this hypothesis wrong.
When Forward Becomes Avoidance
Looking forward can become a way to avoid saying something difficult. If we skip the Behavior and Impact entirely, the other person may never learn what actually happened. Moreover, some situations call for clear, direct correction, such as safety risks or ethical breaches. In those moments, kindness means clarity first. The forward conversation can follow once the line is clear.
When Yet Sounds Patronizing
The word yet can also misfire. Said from above, it may sound like a teacher patting a student’s head. Similarly, it can imply the person must change toward a standard they never chose. That is why the Opportunity works best when it reflects the other person’s own aspiration. Otherwise, yet quietly becomes another verdict.
When an Open Question Does Not Feel Safe to Answer
Power changes how a question lands. When a manager asks, “What was going on for you?”, an employee may hear a trap. After all, an honest answer could cost them something. In Curiosity Reciprocity, we explore a simple test: is curiosity safe to return? For this reason, the person with more power carries more responsibility for making it safe. Sometimes that means going first, perhaps by naming what we might have done differently ourselves. Amy Edmondson’s research on psychological safety helps explain why. Yet-Forward Feedback depends on that safety more than it creates it.
When someone disagrees with our feedback, their willingness to speak up can be a gift. We can appreciate that candor while remaining genuinely curious about what we might have missed. It also helps to distinguish genuine requirements from our preferences or traditions. We need not abandon a necessary expectation to remain open about how someone might meet it. If emotions run high, a pause may create room for a more productive conversation. Care, curiosity, and clarity can coexist.
When Yet Needs Accountability
Yet does not mean indefinitely. When progress stalls, curiosity helps us understand what might be getting in the way. Is the gap one of clarity, skill, opportunity, motivation, or support? Together, we can explore what would help while making expectations and time frames explicit. Written agreements and follow-up can reinforce shared understanding. Accountability need not replace encouragement. Instead, both can help someone recognize the opportunity ahead while understanding the consequences if meaningful progress does not follow.
What the Evidence Does and Does Not Show
The research beneath this approach deserves careful reading. Kluger and DeNisi’s meta-analysis shows that feedback can harm performance, especially when it targets the self. That finding is well established. However, the evidence for growth mindset interventions is much more contested. In 2023, Brooke Macnamara and Alexander Burgoyne reviewed these studies. They concluded that apparent effects on achievement likely reflected weak design and bias. A competing meta-analysis in the same journal found meaningful effects for some groups of students.
So what can we fairly say? The evidence clearly supports keeping feedback focused on the task rather than the self. It supports, more tentatively, the value of language that frames ability as changeable. Beyond that, SBIQO is a lens I am proposing, not a proven intervention. I offer it as a hypothesis to test in your own conversations.
A Yet-Forward Feedback Conversation About a Promotion
A Yet-Forward Feedback conversation with an ambitious employee often takes only a few minutes to begin. Here is one way the dreaded review from the start of this page might sound. The employee wants a promotion, and the manager sees a real path to it.
“I know a promotion and a raise matter a lot to you. I see a path to both. Would you like to explore it together?”
“In last week’s design review, you defended your approach before others finished their questions. Afterward, two teammates told me they stopped raising concerns.”
“What was going on for you in that moment?”
“At the next level, people draw out concerns before the team decides. You haven’t had the chance to show that yet. What might you try in the next review?”
Notice how the conversation begins with what the employee wants, not with what went wrong. The Situation, Behavior, and Impact take only two sentences. Meanwhile, the levels matrix supplies the yet, and the employee designs the next step. Everything else belongs to their perspective and their future.
Practicing Yet-Forward Feedback With AI
Practicing Yet-Forward Feedback before a real conversation can make the real one far calmer. The actors in my training session offered exactly that kind of rehearsal. Today, an AI collaborator can play a similar role. You can describe the situation, then ask the AI to respond as a skeptical or defensive employee.
For example, a practice prompt might begin like this: “Play an ambitious employee who feels underpaid and resists feedback. I’ll practice an SBIQO conversation with you. Push back realistically.” Then try moving through all five steps. Afterward, ask the AI to step out of role and reflect on how it went.
- Where did my observation sound like a judgment?
- Did my question invite an honest answer, or quietly steer one?
- Did the Opportunity belong to them, or to me?
As we explore in AI People Ops, AI can provide the mirror. The human still decides what to learn from the reflection. Rehearsal also has limits. An AI cannot know the real person, their history, or the trust between you. Likewise, keep confidential details about real colleagues out of any AI tool. Practice can steady your own posture, but it should never script the other person.
The same principles apply when coaching a colleague to give peer feedback. Rather than stepping in on their behalf, we can help them prepare, rehearse, and reflect on a conversation they can own.
Questions to Carry Into Your Next Feedback Conversation
Before your next feedback conversation, it may help to pause with a few questions of your own. These are not tests. Rather, they are invitations to notice where you already practice Yet-Forward Feedback, and where you might not yet.
- Am I hoping to help this person grow, or hoping to be proven right?
- What do I genuinely not know about their side of this?
- What would “even more effective” mean to them, not only to me?
- Which feedback I received once helped me grow, and what made it work?

How Yet-Forward Feedback Compares With Other Feedback Models
Yet-Forward Feedback shares instincts with other models I found after writing this page. Some already end with a question, and one begins by asking permission. The table compares them, so readers can see what each emphasizes.
| Model | Structure | Where it points |
|---|---|---|
| SBI, Center for Creative Leadership | Situation, Behavior, Impact | Ends with a statement of impact |
| SBII, Center for Creative Leadership | SBI plus a question about Intent | Explores intent behind the behavior |
| Feedforward, Marshall Goldsmith | Suggestions about the future only | Skips the past entirely |
| Feedback Equation, Lara Hogan | Observation, Impact, Request or Question | Ends with a request or, often better, a question |
| Feedback Model, Manager Tools | Ask permission, Behavior, Impact, Next steps | Asks what the person can do differently |
| Radical Candor, Kim Scott Candor Rituals, CD’s take on R.C. | Care personally while challenging directly | A relational stance rather than a sequence of steps |
| Feed Up, Feed Back, Feed Forward, Hattie and Timperley | Where am I going? How am I going? Where to next? | Points learning toward the next step |
| Yet-Forward Feedback, SBIQO | Shared direction, brief SBI, Open Question, Opportunity, and yet | Gives most of the conversation to their future, in their words |
What Yet-Forward Feedback adds is less any single step than the combination. It begins with the other person’s own aspiration. It separates the Open Question from an Opportunity they own. It gives most of the time to the future, frames gaps with yet against their own standard, and extends the same structure to praise. It also names where the approach can go wrong, rather than presenting it as proven.
Glossary of Yet-Forward Feedback Terms
Accidental Diminisher
- Liz Wiseman’s term for a well-meaning leader who shrinks others’ thinking by rescuing or fixing too quickly.
Curiosity Reciprocity
- A Talent Whisperers concept. Curiosity tends to invite curiosity in return, while defensiveness tends to invite more defensiveness.
Executive Fix-It Mode
- The leadership habit of jumping straight to solutions before understanding what the other person needs.
Feed Forward
- In John Hattie and Helen Timperley’s feedback model, the question “Where to next?” that points learning toward the next step.
Feedforward
- Marshall Goldsmith’s term for suggestions about the future, offered instead of judgments about the past.
Levels Matrix
- A grid of levels and skills that describes what each skill looks like at each level of a role.
Open Question
- The fourth step of SBIQO. It is a genuine question that invites the other person’s perspective, intent, and context.
Opportunity
- The fifth step of SBIQO. It is a forward-looking next step, ideally named by the other person.
Psychological Safety
- Amy Edmondson’s term for a shared belief that it is safe to speak up, ask questions, and admit mistakes.
SBI (Situation, Behavior, Impact)
- A feedback model from the Center for Creative Leadership that keeps feedback specific, observable, and free of judgment.
SBIQO (Situation, Behavior, Impact, Open Question, Opportunity)
- The five-step structure of Yet-Forward Feedback. It extends SBI with an Open Question and a forward-looking opportunity.
Wise Feedback
- Critical feedback paired with high standards and confidence that the person can meet them. David Yeager and colleagues studied it in classrooms.
Yet
- A small word that frames a gap as a point on a path rather than a fixed trait.
Yet-Forward Feedback
- A Talent Whisperers approach to feedback that points toward opportunity, keeps yet in view, and asks before it tells.
Frequently Asked Questions About Yet-Forward Feedback
How is Yet-Forward Feedback different from feedforward?
- Feedforward asks only for suggestions about the future. Yet-Forward Feedback keeps a brief, honest anchor in what happened. It then adds an Open Question and the language of yet.
Does Yet-Forward Feedback replace the SBI model?
- No. It builds on SBI. Situation, Behavior, and Impact remain the foundation, while the Open Question and Opportunity extend the conversation forward.
Can I use Yet-Forward Feedback for praise?
- Yes. Asking what made something work, and where else it might help, turns appreciation into a pattern someone can repeat.
How can I use Yet-Forward Feedback in a performance review?
- A levels matrix helps. Agree on the year’s aim, then explore skills the person has not yet had the chance to demonstrate. Frame them as opportunities to show proficiency, not as deficiencies.
Can I practice Yet-Forward Feedback with AI?
- Yes. An AI can play a skeptical employee while you practice the five SBIQO steps. Afterward, ask it where you sounded judgmental. Keep confidential details about real colleagues out of the tool.
Isn’t forward-looking feedback just a way to avoid hard truths?
- It should not be. Situation, Behavior, and Impact keep an honest anchor in what happened. Looking forward changes the direction of the conversation, not its honesty.
What if the other person does not feel safe answering my question?
- Power can make any question feel risky. Consider going first, perhaps by naming what you might have done differently. Asking permission at the start also helps.
When should I not use Yet-Forward Feedback?
- Safety risks, ethical breaches, and urgent problems usually need direct, clear correction first. A forward-looking conversation can follow once the immediate issue is resolved.
What is SBIQO?
SBIQO stands for Situation, Behavior, Impact, Open Question, and Opportunity. It is the five-step structure of Yet-Forward Feedback. The first three steps come from the Center for Creative Leadership’s SBI model. The Open Question invites the other person’s perspective before we assume their intent. The Opportunity is a next step, ideally named by the other person, in the spirit of yet. Each step, with an example, appears in SBIQO: The Five Steps of Yet-Forward Feedback
Research and Editorial Process
This page grew from decades of giving, receiving, and coaching feedback across many companies and teams. During its development, I used several large language models as research and editorial tools. They helped discover sources, surface questions, compare interpretations, and challenge assumptions. They also helped audit drafts, check consistency, and verify claims against available source material. Along the way, they helped me notice omissions, competing interpretations, and places where language outran the evidence. Wherever quotation marks appear, I have sought to trace the words to their original source.
The synthesis, judgments, framework connections, and final editorial choices remain mine. I have treated AI much as I would other powerful research tools. It is useful for widening the field of inquiry. However, it is not a substitute for examining sources, exercising judgment, or taking responsibility for what is published.
About the Author
My interest in feedback began long before I had a name for SBIQO. In college, I worked as a bartender and waiter for U.Va.’s Executive Program. Over drinks, I heard top executives discuss how they met and overcame challenges.
My first job after college was as an architect of the world’s first integrated software development environment. I later helped major corporations around the world implement it. Since then, I have served as an executive across 11 disruptive technology companies. Each faced a crisis that threatened its survival. All survived, and seven reached billion-dollar-plus valuations against the odds. Along the way, I saw how often criticism produced defensiveness. I also saw how often a forward-looking question opened possibility.
Coaching a team to a national championship taught me something similar. Talent alone did not explain performance. Confidence, attention, and the voices athletes carried into competition mattered too.
My formal coaching training began in 2018 through Co-Active Coaching and Positive Intelligence Coaching. Talent Whisperers is where those strands increasingly meet. Yet-Forward Feedback is part of that continuing inquiry rather than a claim to have reached its end.
See Also
Yet-Forward Feedback draws on many voices, both within the Talent Whisperers ecosystem and well beyond it. The resources below offer deeper perspectives, supporting research, and a few thoughtful challenges.
Within the Talent Whisperers Ecosystem
Evaluation and Motivation, Talent Whisperers
This page explores why evaluation so often undermines the motivation it hopes to build. It suggests that people frequently hear feedback as a signal about belonging rather than as neutral information. It traces that pattern through parenting, leadership, classrooms, and our own inner voices. Readers will find the deeper reasons why backward-looking criticism tends to trigger defense.
Powerful Questions, Talent Whisperers
This page gathers questions and listening practices that open conversations rather than close them. It includes question banks by category, active listening techniques, and deeper practices of transformational inquiry. For anyone practicing the Open Question step of SBIQO, it offers many more starting points. It also explores how silence and listening shape what a question can reveal.
Performance Reviews: Catalysts for Growth, Atomic Rituals
This companion piece reframes performance reviews as leadership rituals that strengthen people rather than judge them. It recommends beginning with someone’s career ambitions instead of their past shortcomings. It also describes a shared job levels matrix that makes reviews more collaborative. Readers will find a fuller treatment of the review practices behind Yet-Forward Feedback.
Radical Candor, Talent Whisperers
This earlier post explores the trust-first practices that let honest feedback be heard as help. It builds on Kim Scott’s Radical Candor with five foundational rituals, including assuming positive intent. It also covers receiving candor, offering it upward, and the outside pressures that shape how feedback lands. Readers will find the relationship groundwork that makes Yet-Forward Feedback possible.
Do Not Become a Servant Leader, Talent Whisperers
This post argues that servant leadership can drift into servitude, shielding people from every discomfort. It draws a line between being nice and being kind. Niceness makes someone comfortable right now, while kindness stretches them toward growth. It also explores Liz Wiseman’s accidental diminisher and the quiet cost of rescuing too quickly. Readers will find the leadership stance beneath Yet-Forward Feedback: caring enough to invite real effort.
Curiosity Reciprocity: Transforming Conflict into Connection, Talent Whisperers
This page explores how sincere curiosity about another person’s view tends to invite curiosity in return. Defensiveness, by contrast, tends to provoke more defensiveness. It also examines executive fix-it mode and how power shapes whether curiosity feels safe to return. Readers will find why asking before telling can change the tone of an entire conversation.
Saboteurs and Allies: Master Your Inner Voices, Talent Whisperers
This page explores the inner voices that either drain our confidence or strengthen it. It suggests that even a harsh inner critic carries a kernel of positive intent. Rather than silencing that critic, it invites us to notice the need behind its message. Readers who walk into feedback already braced for judgment may recognize those voices here.
Learned Resilience: Beyond Grit, Talent Whisperers
This page describes resilience as a learnable skill rather than a fixed trait. It proposes taking on progressively harder challenges that stretch capacity without overwhelming it. Each cycle of challenge, reflection, and recovery can establish a new and higher baseline. Readers will find a natural partner to the idea that growth unfolds one yet at a time.
Weathering Storms: How Startups Build Learned Resilience and Thrive Through Uncertainty, Talent Whisperers
This page explores how startups and their teams learn through crises rather than merely survive them. It treats candid feedback as a gift and favors blameless post-mortems that turn failures into learning. It also recommends clear rubrics showing what each level of a role requires. Readers will find the wider setting where Yet-Forward Feedback helps people grow through uncertainty.
AI People Ops: Orchestrated Evolution in the Age of AI, AI Whispering
This page explores how people operations evolve as intelligent tools join hiring, onboarding, and manager development. It describes AI coaching tools that surface growth themes, and practice spaces where new leaders build skills safely. Throughout, it treats AI as a mirror, while humans decide what to learn from the reflection. Readers will find the wider people systems in which Yet-Forward Feedback can take root.
The Unseen Hand: Deconstructing the Essence of a Talent Whisperer, Talent Whisperers
This page describes the quiet influence at the heart of Talent Whispering. It focuses on cultivating conditions for growth rather than chasing outcomes. Success, in this view, means others grow until they no longer need us. Its aspiration to leave behind ripples rather than footprints shapes the spirit of Yet-Forward Feedback.
Slide Deck
Google Slide Deck on Google Drive
Beyond Talent Whisperers
Use Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) To Understand Intent, Center for Creative Leadership
The Center for Creative Leadership created the SBI model, and this article explains it step by step. It also introduces SBII, which adds a step for asking about the other person’s intent. The article argues that asking closes the gap between intent and impact. It shows why moving from one-way feedback to two-way conversation builds trust.
Try Feedforward Instead of Feedback, Marshall Goldsmith
Marshall Goldsmith introduces feedforward and offers eleven reasons it can outperform traditional feedback. He argues that we can change the future but not the past. He also describes a simple exercise in which people ask for two suggestions about the future. Readers will find the origin of the forward-looking stance that Yet-Forward Feedback builds upon.
Feedback Equation, Lara Hogan
Lara Hogan offers a compact formula for feedback: Observation plus Impact plus a Request or Question. She follows one running example through every step, which makes the structure easy to grasp. She also contrasts observations with judgments, using side-by-side examples. Notably, she suggests that a genuinely curious question often works better than a request. Readers will find a close cousin of SBIQO’s Open Question, presented with admirable clarity.
The Manager Tools Feedback Model, Right Attitudes
This article summarizes the feedback model taught by the Manager Tools podcast. It begins by asking permission, then names the behavior and its impact. For corrective feedback, it closes by asking what the person can do differently. Each step comes with short example language. Readers will find another model that shares Yet-Forward Feedback’s instinct to ask before telling.
The Power of Feedback, John Hattie and Helen Timperley
This widely cited 2007 review in the Review of Educational Research examines what makes feedback effective. It proposes three guiding questions. Where am I going? How am I going? Where to next? The authors call that third question feed forward. Readers will find an academic foundation for pointing feedback toward the next step.
The Power of Yet (The Power of Believing That You Can Improve), Carol Dweck
In this 2014 TEDx talk, Carol Dweck describes the difference between a fixed and a growth mindset. She shares the idea of a “Not Yet” grade that frames struggle as part of learning. The talk is short and accessible, and it appears under two titles. YouTube carries the original TEDx recording, while TED.com adds a full transcript. It offers the clearest introduction to the power of yet that this page draws upon.
See Also: Carol Dweck the Power of Believing that you can improve
Multipliers: How the Best Leaders Make Everyone Smarter, Liz Wiseman
This book contrasts two kinds of leaders. Diminishers drain the intelligence and capability of the people around them. Multipliers draw out more of the thinking their people already have. The revised edition adds a chapter on the accidental diminisher, the well-meaning leader who rescues too quickly. Wiseman’s research suggests most diminishing happens this way, with the best of intentions. Readers will find a mirror for the moments when helping quietly takes the thinking away.
The Effects of Feedback Interventions on Performance, Avraham Kluger and Angelo DeNisi
This 1996 meta-analysis in Psychological Bulletin reviewed over six hundred feedback effects. It found that feedback improved performance on average but reduced it in over a third of cases. The authors proposed that feedback loses power as it shifts attention toward the self. Readers interested in the evidence behind task-focused feedback will find it here.
The Feedforward Interview, Avraham Kluger and Dina Nir
Building on Appreciative Inquiry, this 2010 paper proposes an interview that asks people to recall moments when they thrived. The authors suggest it could complement or even replace parts of the traditional performance review. They also call for further research to test when it works best. Kluger’s research page collects this paper alongside later field studies.
Looking Forward to Performance Improvement, Marie-Hélène Budworth, Gary Latham, and Laxmikant Manroop
This 2015 study in Human Resource Management tested the Feedforward Interview inside a real company. Employees were randomly assigned to either a feedforward interview or a traditional performance appraisal. Those in the feedforward group later showed higher performance. Readers will find early field evidence that forward-looking review conversations can work in practice.
The Feedback Fallacy, Marcus Buckingham and Ashley Goodall
This 2019 Harvard Business Review article challenges the belief that frequent critical feedback helps people thrive. The authors argue that people grow most in their areas of greatest strength. They suggest paying close attention to what is already working and what comes next. Readers will find a thoughtful case for feedback that builds on strengths rather than fixing flaws.
Give Employees the Right Kind of Feedback at the Right Time, Chris Musser, Gallup
This Gallup article sorts feedback by whether a problem involves hard or soft skills. It also asks whether the failure is objective or subjective. That sorting yields four types: collaborative, investigative, informative, and corrective. Several of them close with a plan for next time rather than a verdict. The article also reports that only 26% of employees strongly agree their feedback helps them do better work. Readers will find practical help in matching feedback to the problem in front of them.
Breaking the Cycle of Mistrust: Wise Interventions to Provide Critical Feedback, David Yeager and Colleagues
In these randomized field experiments, teachers attached a short note to their critical feedback on student essays. The note said the comments reflected high expectations and confidence that the student could reach them. Students who received it were more likely to revise and wrote stronger revisions. Effects were largest among African American students who mistrusted school. Readers will find striking evidence that pairing high standards with genuine belief changes how feedback lands.
Thanks for the Feedback, Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen
This book looks at feedback from the receiver’s side of the conversation. The authors describe three triggers that make feedback hard to hear: truth, relationship, and identity. Identity triggers arise when feedback challenges the story we tell about ourselves. Readers will find practical insight into why even well-intended feedback can provoke defense.
How to Receive Feedback, Parts 1 and 2, The Management Center
This two-part guide looks at feedback from the receiver’s side. Part 1 suggests calming the body first, since critical feedback can trigger a threat response. It then recommends asking clarifying questions and deciding deliberately what to act on. Part 2 explores receiving feedback when power, difference, or inequity is part of the picture. Readers will find practical steps for staying curious when feedback is hard to hear.
Psychological Safety, Amy C. Edmondson
Amy Edmondson’s research shows why people need to feel safe before they speak up, ask questions, or admit mistakes. Her site gathers articles, videos, and tools for building psychological safety in teams. Without that safety, even the most forward-looking feedback can feel risky. Readers will find the broader team conditions that help Yet-Forward Feedback take root.
Self-Determination Theory, Edward Deci and Richard Ryan
Self-Determination Theory is one of the most widely researched theories of human motivation. It holds that people thrive when their needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness are met. Inviting someone to name their own Opportunity speaks directly to that need for autonomy. Readers will find research, questionnaires, and resources on motivation at work and in education.
Do Growth Mindset Interventions Impact Students’ Academic Achievement?, Brooke Macnamara and Alexander Burgoyne
This 2023 meta-analysis offers an important counterweight to popular enthusiasm about growth mindset. The authors concluded that apparent effects likely reflected weak study design, reporting flaws, and bias. A competing analysis in the same journal reached a more positive conclusion for some groups. Readers will find a careful reason to hold the power of yet lightly.
